"Do I have enough?" - answering retirees' toughest question

Key takeaways from our decumulation roundtable with insurance, pensions and wealth leaders: retirement income, product silos, trust and the role of AI.


"Do I have enough?" is the starting point for most when it comes to planning their retirement finances. Makes sense as a first step from a customer's perspective, but for the industry, answering that question is anything but simple.

We spent an evening with people across the insurance, pensions and wealth industry to discuss the hot topic of decumulation. Exploring how companies can service their customers well as they transition from accumulating their savings and assets, towards taking money out (decumulating) as they begin funding their retirement.

As always, the dinner ran under Chatham House Rules, so what follows is an interpretation of the key ideas, challenges, and solutions put forward by our guests.

It should be simple, right?DSC01163

Asking "Is what I have saved enough to pay for my retirement?" could be mistaken for a simple request. Many would think: add up my pension pots, savings, investments, and other assets into one big bundle and tell me if it’s 'enough'.

The key problem, though, is that you can’t really say what ‘enough’ is. A simple tool could model a yearly income and give you ‘enough’. But for what, for how long, and for whom? The answers to these questions depend on things no single provider can see: a partner's pension, a mortgage that hasn't quite been paid off, a parent who may need care, a job that could end at 60 or at 67, and variable multiple incomes. The person asking often can't see all of it either. So a seemingly straightforward question is met with a far less straightforward answer.

The industry reality

Most firms in this market call themselves customer-centric, and they mean it. The difficulty expressed by many of the practitioners and leaders around the table is that the organisations behind the words are still built around the products they sell. The pension products sit in one part of the business, the protection policies in another, and the savings in a third - each with its own P&L, systems, and targets. Customers see none of this; while they’re thinking about specific events and retirement aspirations, the industry is busy chasing around to join together a vast range of 'solutions' that underpin those aims.

Nobody suggested this is simple to fix. Product lines exist for good reasons, including regulation and how the money is made. But the point was made that someone asking "Do I have enough?" is asking about everything at once. And a single product - whether an annuity, SIPP or a blended product - is only ever answering part of the story.

One instinct is to answer with a better portfolio: more personalised, more closely matched to someone's appetite for risk. There’s some value in this, though the discussion we heard suggested it is the smaller part of the job. Retirement is mostly planned by households. Two people of different ages, with different pensions, different health, and different ideas about when to stop working (if at all) are making one set of decisions between them. And they are making them without knowing how long they will live or what care needs they may have. There’s no silver-bullet piece of technology or approach that ties this all together.

DSC00980

DSC01330

Trust and AI

That leaves trust at the centre of the debate. Since Pension Freedoms, the exodus in popularity of annuities (which in many ways made the job of funding retirement far simpler, particularly for the majority of people who do not access financial advice regularly), and the rise of Defined Contribution pensions, people are asked to make large decisions, some of them irreversible, on the strength of someone else's forecast. Whether they act seems to depend less on how precise the forecast is than on whether they believe whoever produced it understands their situation. A personalised portfolio doesn't earn that by itself.

Having taken a moment to really characterise the challenge at hand here, the conversation moved on to the topic of industry change and disruption. Cue the AI conversation. This is where views differed the most. The hopeful case is about access. Full financial advice is expensive, and plenty of people reach retirement without it. Something that can hold a conversation in plain English with a nervous customer, at any hour, about their current circumstances could help. It’s certainly better than the head-in-the-sand approach many still take today.

The cautious case is about being right and being understood. A confident wrong answer does more harm in retirement because the mistakes are hard to undo - sometimes impossibly so. And a correct answer remains risky if the customer agrees to something they haven't grasped. Understanding is much harder to check than accuracy.

No surprises here, but we weren’t able to find a neat AI solution over dinner that evening. There’s always next time.

Where does this leave us?

Changing regulation, legacy technology, organisational bureaucracy, guidance versus advice, and a need for providers to partner better for the benefit of the customer. These are not new challenges per se, but decumulation remains the key topic.DSC00889

People are retiring into a very different financial environment compared to their parents - without gold-plated defined benefit pensions and with a clear need to cut through significant complexity to begin feeling secure and confident in retirement.

The aim of our roundtable was not to find all the answers. It was, as always, to get people talking. Seeing in real time the different perspectives from across the industry knocking together is one of the privileges of working at a consultancy. Perspective is everything in this game, and it will certainly take perspective, innovation, and collaboration to better support customers in and approaching retirement now, as well as long into the future.

"Do I have enough?" is a simple thing to ask. The firms that get to answer it will probably be the ones that start with the person asking and work back to the product. If that question is on your list, we'd like to hear how you're approaching it.

 

N.B. A few practical ideas that seem worth sharing.

  • Language choices: describing what a product does for someone's life in words they would use themselves, so that the answer to a plain question is also plain.
  • Access to support, meaning help that is easier to reach for people who will never pay for full advice.
  • Working together across the value chain. Providers, platforms, advisers and employers each hold part of a customer's picture and none holds all of it. How far firms that compete can share that picture is an open question.

Similar posts

Add a Comment:

Are you looking to build a digital capability?